You say no. They argue. You explain again. It gets louder. Now you're annoyed, and they're accusing you of never letting them do anything. So you start defending yourself, and ten minutes later the two of you are arguing about something that barely resembles the original problem.
At some point, it stopped being about the thing.
I get sucked into power struggles all the time. I joke that I usually don't realize it until I'm about four exchanges in. So if you want to know how to stop arguing with your kids, I'm right there practicing with you.
I'm Mandy Grass, a board-certified behavior analyst and parent coach. On this episode of The Behavior Blueprint, I talked about why power struggles keep happening, why an argument can switch functions halfway through, and how to put down the rope.
Listen to the full episode
This post is based on Why You Keep Arguing With Your Kids and How to Stop. Listen on Apple Podcasts or find The Behavior Blueprint on the podcast page.
It takes two to argue with a child
You can't play tennis with one person. I guess you could hit against a wall, but you definitely can't play tug-of-war by yourself. For a power struggle to exist, there have to be two people pulling on the rope.
We can't control our kids' behavior, but we can control how we respond, and that response should be based on why the argument is happening.
Putting your rope down does not mean ignoring your child's feelings or being permissive. It means recognizing you're now part of a loop that keeps the argument going.
I say this all the time: anything that is existing or increasing is coming in contact with reinforcement. Said more simply, if a behavior is happening, it's working. Kids don't argue with us for no reason. So the question isn't only "How do I make this stop?" It's "What is keeping this going?"
What is the argument doing for your child?
In behavior analysis, there are four functions of behavior:
- Attention. They want to engage with you. And yes, that includes negative attention. Attention is attention. I'll let you in on a secret: negative attention is usually much easier to get.
- Access. They want something tangible. I don't mean access to a friend (that's attention). I mean a literal item. I want the ice cream.
- Escape. They want to get out of doing something. My biggest escape as a kid was hiding the laundry in the closet so I didn't have to put it away.
- Automatic or sensory. Thumb-sucking, nail-biting, bouncing your knee. These absolutely exist, but in a power struggle that involves another person, it's highly unlikely the function is automatic.
If you want the bigger picture on these, my Behavior Basics course walks through all four.
Why the argument changes halfway through
This is the part I really want you to notice: the function can change.
A lot of power struggles start with denied access or escape. Let's say your kid asks for ice cream after dinner and you say, "Not tonight." Then it's, "But you gave my sister some." So I explain that her sister earned cookies for something else, and now I'm standing there defensively explaining how everything in our house is always equal. Meanwhile my child is going on about how I never do anything for them, how everything is harder for them, and how mean I am.
It started as access. Somewhere in there it turned into something else.
Same with hidden laundry. "Did you hide the laundry?" "No." "Why did you do that?" It started as escaping the laundry, and it can turn into a whole back-and-forth.
A lot of power struggles end up attention maintained, even when they didn't start that way. Could the arguing also be delaying the chore? Sure. But often the back-and-forth is the part that's paying off.
Here's a real one from my house. Parker asks if she can go to a friend's house. I say, "Not tonight." Then it's, "You never let me do anything. You always let Lola." And now I'm pulling out the evidence: you went to a friend's house on Tuesday. I keep getting more logical. It doesn't help, because she isn't looking for my logic. The round and round is the point.
If they follow you when you walk away, that's useful information
One question I ask parents all the time in coaching is, "What happens if you walk away?"
A lot of the time, the answer is, "They follow me." "Mom. Mom. I'm talking to you." They get louder. Maybe they throw something, or say the one thing they know you can't resist correcting, like a swear word.
Parents tell me this like it proves walking away doesn't work. I want you to be a little excited about it. Not because it's pleasant. It absolutely isn't. But it tells you something really clear: when you removed your attention, they worked harder to get it back.
One time doesn't prove a function. If you walk away three times and every time they get louder and follow you, that's a pattern. If your child is more like, "Sweet, I don't have to do the laundry anymore," that's a different function. If you're not sure whether it's attention, I walk through how to tell in Is It Defiance or Connection?
Our side of the rope
We also have to talk about the function of our behavior, because we're the other person holding the rope.
When your kid stomps up the stairs and slams the door, a lot of the time they want you to follow. If you're anything like me, you follow them up with heavy feet and open that door. Ask yourself what that's doing for you. A lot of the time it's, "I'm going to end this right now."
A friend of mine was dealing with her son coming out of his room at bedtime. He'd come out, she'd redirect him. He needed a snack. Then water. She threatened to take away the TV. He came out again, and she ended up dramatically unplugging the TV and carrying it out to the garage, which had nothing to do with bedtime. In the moment, it felt like the thing that would show him she meant business.
Then she felt terrible. Most of us would. She went back in, they talked, they apologized, and there was more affection and reassurance.
I want to be super clear: repairing is really good. Apologizing when we mess up is good. But zoom out on that night. The bedtime routine turned into redirecting, arguing, threatening, a dramatic TV removal, another conversation, a repair, and connection. That is so much attention for coming out of his room. Both things can be true. The repair matters, and the whole chain is worth looking at.
Sometimes we yell, it stops, and we think, "I should've just said 'enough' sooner." Relief is reinforcing for parents too. If you're yelling a lot, it's because it's working, at least in the moment. Their behavior changes ours, ours changes theirs, and that back-and-forth is the actual power struggle. We're basically waiting to see who stops first.
When you do give in
This is real life. Some kids ask 14 times and you hold the line, and some days they ask twice and you're like, "Fine, forget it." Sometimes you're cooking, or on the phone, or in Target and you don't want a scene. And sometimes you just change your mind.
If you're going to change your answer, consider changing it right away, or before 20 minutes of escalation, not in the middle of the power struggle. If I only say "fine, get the ice cream" once it's gotten ugly, I'm reinforcing that whole chain of events.
Another option is to take a break. "We're going to take five minutes, and then we'll come back to this." When your child comes back, they can ask respectfully. You can even model it for them: "Hey Mom, could you take a few minutes to think about this and let me know if it might be possible?" I'm working on that wait time with Lola right now, because she tends to respond impulsively.
That might feel silly and nuanced, but think about which skill you want them to learn. "If I wear Mom down, she'll give in"? Or "I can ask, give someone time to think, and come back to it"? Which one is more useful everywhere else? We don't want them learning that persistence and escalation pay off. I'll be honest, it still happens in my house regularly.
And sometimes they have a point. Parker made a genuinely valid argument in one of ours recently. I'm not saying our kids should never debate us. I'm saying we want to notice the pattern.
What putting down the rope sounds like
When you realize you're in it, validate the feeling, keep your answer, and stop participating in the debate. It can sound like:
- "My answer is no, but I'll be happy to talk to you about it when you're ready."
- "I know you're disappointed. The answer is still no."
Then be explicit about how they can get your attention back, and respond when they do it. Function is just information. It tells you what to teach instead.
Expect them to pick the rope back up, because something about it has worked. And if your child is a teenager or this has been your pattern for years, it will take longer to change.
You can also start fresh anytime. I'm not kidding. When I notice we're in a power struggle, I put the rope down in the middle of the argument. Easier said than done, I know.
A few more things that help:
- Look for patterns. What's the function? How often does it happen? What does it look like?
- Ask your partner to hold you accountable. I'm way better at spotting it when Gerry's the one stuck in it than when it's me.
- Aim for progress, not perfection. You'll give in sometimes. You'll yell sometimes. You'll realize halfway through, "Oh my gosh, I'm doing it." No worries. Notice it and start over.
FAQ
How do I stop arguing with my kids when they won't drop it? Put down your side of the rope. Validate the feeling, keep your answer short, and stop debating: "My answer is no, but I'll be happy to talk about it when you're ready." Then tell them exactly how to get your attention back, and respond right away when they do. Expect them to push harder at first, because the arguing has worked before.
Why do power struggles with kids keep happening even when I never give in? If a behavior keeps happening, something is reinforcing it. If you truly never change your answer, the payoff is often somewhere else, like the attention that comes with the back-and-forth. Look at what happens around the argument, not just the final answer.
How do I end a power struggle with a toddler? The same idea works at any age: it takes two people to keep a power struggle going. Keep your words few, skip the round after round of explaining, and show them how to get your attention or ask for what they want. Then respond when they do it.
A next step, if you want one
If you want help figuring out what's keeping the arguments going in your house, that's what 1:1 coaching is for. Sometimes it's one simple tweak to how we respond. If you'd rather have ongoing support while you practice, The Club is where I answer your real-life questions.
And if your kid seems to save the arguing just for you, you might like Why Does My Kid Only Act Like This With Me? next.
So the next time you're four exchanges in, ask two questions: what is my child's behavior doing for them, and what is mine doing for me? Then put the rope down.