Is It Defiance or Connection? How to Spot Attention-Seeking Behavior in Children

We talk a lot about attention-maintained behavior on my podcast. The kid whines because they want your attention. They storm off because they want you to follow. You get it.

Except in your house, it doesn't look that simple. It looks like, "Why do I have to take this medication?" "Why didn't I get to go to the sleepover?" "Why did you go to Timmy's game instead of mine?" "You never do anything for me. You love everyone else more than me."

And suddenly, if you're anything like me, you're 12 minutes into defending yourself against a 14-year-old when you were just trying to get in the car.

That is what attention seeking behavior in children can actually look like. Sometimes it looks a lot like defiance.

I'm Mandy Grass, a board-certified behavior analyst and parent coach. On this episode of The Behavior Blueprint, I walked through a coaching session where I could literally see the behavior chain unfolding as the parent described it, and what to do once you recognize the pattern.

Listen to the full episode

This post is based on Is It Defiance or Connection? How to Spot Attention-Seeking Patterns. Listen on Apple Podcasts or find The Behavior Blueprint on the podcast page.

The morning that was never about the medication

The parent I was coaching has a daughter with ADHD who takes medication in the morning. One morning her daughter said she didn't want to take it. She didn't like it. She didn't like the way it felt.

First of all, I'm not a doctor, and those are totally fair things to feel. The mom thought so too. She told her daughter they would have a real conversation about how the medication makes her feel, but for today, if she didn't want to take it, that was okay. She didn't lecture. She set it down and walked away.

That's exactly what I would have suggested. She dropped her rope. (A power struggle is like tug-of-war: it takes two people pulling. Dropping the rope means you stop pulling. You stay calm, keep your answer, and step out of the back-and-forth instead of arguing your side.)

Then her daughter said, "Are you mad at me?" Mom said no. "But you seem mad." "I'm not mad." "You are." Back and forth. Mom disengaged again. And then her daughter took the pill anyway, in the most dramatic way possible. The water, the pill, the big "I took it."

As I listened, so much became clear. We assumed she didn't want the medication because she didn't like it, which was fair, because that's what she said. But the mom removed that variable, and it still turned into something else. If it had really been about escaping the medication, she would have just not taken it and moved on.

I'm not saying there's nothing deeper going on. Maybe she worries about other people's feelings. That's fair. But in behavior analysis we work with what is observable and measurable, and when you look at the whole chain, there's a missing attention piece.

This is also how we test our guesses. If the parent had just described this to me, I would have said escape. Mom dropped the rope, the behavior continued, so it wasn't escape.

Is it defiance or attention? Look at the ratio

If her daughter had just taken the medication, maybe Mom says, "Great job." Maybe not. Now picture the morning where she doesn't: "Why aren't you taking it? It's time. Did you take it yet? Do you need some water? What's going on?"

That's about six interactions for not taking the medication and maybe one for taking it.

I asked this mom, "Would you have said 'good job' if she'd just taken it?" She said no, she probably wouldn't have.

So when parents ask me, "Why would anyone want to fight with me this much?" the answer is pretty simple. Negative behaviors are predictable attention.

This family has four kids, and Mom is on her own a lot because of work schedules. Guess what's hard to come by? Attention. And this child figured out exactly how to get it. We respond to the topic. I want you to look at the function.

Why "just ignore it" is only half the plan

When I hear "don't give it any attention," it honestly kind of freaks me out, because that's only half of it.

When a behavior is attention maintained, we remove our attention and outline how to get it back. If we only drop the rope, we aren't teaching our kid how to connect with us. And it usually gets worse before it gets better.

That's called an extinction burst. It used to work, it isn't working now, so they up the ante to see if it will. It's the vending machine idea I talked about in Why Does My Kid Only Act Like This With Me?: if it's paid off before, they'll keep pushing the button. Stay as consistent as you can about when your attention is available.

I'm not recommending that you ignore. I'm recommending that we don't forget to teach.

The teaching part is harder. It's way easier to see what you want to change: the bus was late, the uniform was missing, nobody brushed their hair. It's much harder to notice that everybody had their backpack, or that Marley made sure her sister had the water she forgot.

You can also offer attention before it turns into a fight: "It really seems like you need some attention right now. When we get in the car, let's take five minutes to talk." Who has time for that in the morning? Well, you're already spending that time going back and forth.

When your child says you love their sibling more

Same family. Four kids means bouncing between games. Mom missed the first few minutes of her daughter's volleyball game, and of course, that's when her daughter served really well. Mom watched the rest of the game. They got in the car, and her daughter exploded.

This mom said something so many parents feel: the irony is that her daughter feels like she gets no attention, when Mom actually feels bad for her other kids because of how much attention this one gets. If you have a child with ADHD, you might know that feeling.

If that were my kid, I'd immediately start defending myself: I was at your game, I do everything for you. So I have to take myself out of it. It is valid that she feels another child was chosen over her. The way she's expressing it isn't the best.

So instead, validate the feeling and replace the behavior:

"I can tell you're really disappointed that I missed the first few minutes of your game. Truthfully, I'm disappointed too. It feels like there's something more we should talk about. When you're ready to talk, I'm ready to listen. You can tell me, 'Mom, I'm ready now.'"

It's a delicate dance. We don't want such a big reaction that our kids stop telling us things, and we don't want to say every behavior is fine. In big families especially, kids can learn that the louder voice gets heard. We want them to learn to say, "Hey Mom, I feel disappointed."

Watch out for two traps: falling on your sword ("You're right, I'm the worst mom ever") or defending yourself. Either can keep the cycle going.

Make your attention easy to find

Stick to a script, and be super explicit about how your attention is available. "I can tell you're really upset. It's okay to be upset. I'll be happy to talk to you when ___."

Fill in the blank with something your child can actually see themselves doing: when you've taken three deep breaths, when you can talk to me at a speaking volume, when you can tell me you're ready. Try to avoid "when you're calm" or "when you're kind." Those are hard to measure, and I trip myself up with this too.

Other ways to say it:

  • "When you're ready to problem-solve, come find me."
  • "I'll know you're ready to chat when you're sitting at the counter."

If the door slams and they march upstairs, it's okay to go up and say, "I can tell you're having big feelings. I'm ready to talk when..." If it escalates, keep everybody safe, remove your attention, and repeat how to get it back every few minutes.

I once worked with a family whose child was having really severe tantrums. We removed attention and outlined how to get it back. By the fourth tantrum, the child said, "Please don't go away." That's the function, right there.

Then comes the part you cannot skip. When they come back the way you asked, give them so much attention. Put the phone down. The arguing used to get your attention every single time, so the new way needs to get it every time too.

Repair, and the bigger conversation

Repair is essential. Lola and Parker got into a fight the other night and I was frustrated with Lola. Later I was lying in bed thinking about how I should have handled it. I wanted so badly to go fix it right then, but repair in the morning can be just as effective. It's okay to delay the repair. Just come back to it.

When your child does tell you something hard, even if they screamed it, they've given you a chance to adjust. You can circle back: "I know you were really upset, and what you said made sense. Maybe next time I can go to volleyball first. Which games matter most to you?"

And don't drop the bigger conversation. I don't think medication should be an off-the-cuff yes-or-no every morning. If you, your child, and your doctor have decided on it, sit down and talk about it. With this family, we talked about her noting how her days went on medication days and off days, so she could see the connection herself. It's fine to drop the rope that day. Just revisit it.

Look at your side of the pattern

Not every emotional reaction is attention maintained. A child can genuinely believe everyone is being mean to them. Don't dismiss the emotion. Look at what happens after it shows up, and how you're contributing.

I'm working on this myself. When a kid says, "That's not fair, she had a sleepover," I want to bust out the calendar. Instead I can say, "You're right, she had more social time than you this week, and that probably doesn't feel great. Consolation prize, you get to hang out with me."

And just recently I got sucked into a 20-minute sandwich debate and realized it only happens with me, not the other adults in the house. Why? I engage intermittently and I negotiate way too much. Work in progress.

FAQ

What does attention seeking behavior in children look like? Not just whining or tugging. It can look like arguing, "Are you mad at me?", "You never let me do anything," or "You love everyone else more." If the behavior keeps going after you've removed whatever it seemed to be about, attention may be part of the function.

How do I ignore attention seeking without making it worse? Don't just ignore. Remove your attention from the behavior and tell them exactly how to get it back, then give lots of attention when they do. Expect it to get worse before it gets better, and stay consistent.

What do I say when my child says I love their sibling more? Validate without defending yourself or falling on your sword: "I can tell you're really disappointed. When you're ready to talk, I'm ready to listen."

A next step, if you want one

If you want the foundation, Behavior Basics walks through the four functions of behavior. If you'd like support while you practice, The Club has live Q&As and a place to ask me your real-life questions. And if you want help seeing your family's pattern, that's what 1:1 coaching is for.

Attention is powerful. So instead of asking, "How do I stop giving this behavior attention?" ask, "How do I want my child to get my attention instead?"

Previous
Previous

Why You Keep Arguing With Your Kids (and How to Stop)

Next
Next

Why Kids With ADHD Forget Everything (and How to Help Without Constant Reminders)