Is bedtime a battle in your house? One more hug. One more drink. In and out of their room 400 times. Night wakings. Up at 4 a.m. All the things slowly driving you to the brink of insanity.
I get it. In my house, I've prioritized our bedtime routine and revisited it many, many times over the years, because I am done at 8 p.m. I want to sit on the couch for a minute. I needed that routine to be tight for my own sanity. And I work with so many parents who tell me, "I can't do this anymore. Bedtime is taking an hour."
I'm Mandy Grass, a board-certified behavior analyst and parent coach. One important note before we start: I am not a sleep specialist. I can't tell you what time your child should go to bed or when they should drop their nap. What I focus on is the behavior around sleep. And that is something we can change, sometimes really quickly.
We'll break this into three parts: bedtime (the routine and the stalling), night wakings, and the early-morning waker.
Listen to the full episode
This post is based on Bedtime Battles: A Blueprint for Sleep Transitions and Silent Nights. Listen on Apple Podcasts or find The Behavior Blueprint on the podcast page.
First, figure out the function
Bedtime resistance can start at any moment. It might start when dessert comes out, or the second you say, "Time for a bath." In behavior analysis, that signal is called the discriminative stimulus: whatever tells your child, "FYI, bedtime is coming." That's when the behavior starts.
Then we look at function, meaning why the behavior is happening, what it gets your child. Bedtime behavior usually falls into one of two categories:
- Escape: getting out of (or delaying) bedtime.
- Attention: getting more of you.
It can be hard to tell which one it is. I worked with a mom whose son ran down to the basement to play every time she said it was time for bed. She was sure it was escape. So I asked her to walk me through it. She'd go down, say "time to come up," he'd run away from her, she'd go back up, then come back down five minutes later.
That sounded like a game of cat and mouse to me. Maybe it wasn't escape. Maybe it was attention.
So I had her try something different: "I'll be happy to read you books when you've finished your bath." Then she walked away. He came upstairs within a few minutes.
If it had been escape, walking away would have backfired. He would have thought, "Sweet, nobody's watching me, I'm hanging out in the basement." That's why function matters so much. And sometimes it's trial and error. Make your best guess, act on it for a few days, and if the behavior doesn't change, switch.
Build a bedtime routine kids can follow
Have a consistent routine and clear expectations. For younger kids, roughly seven and under, consider a social story: a short, simple story that walks your child through what happens and what they'll do.
We used one in my house. The transition from bath to pajamas to brushing teeth was a mess of naked giggles, booty slapping, and running around. Listen, I love good fun. But at the end of the day, I'm tapped. So I wrote a social story for my girls. It said, more or less: when the bath is done, I need to get dressed. Mommy will set a timer for five minutes. If I get my jammies on and get back to the bathroom before the timer goes off, I can earn an audiobook.
I paired it with a visual timer. My favorite is a free app called Visual Countdown Timer, which slowly reveals a picture as time runs down. Little kids have no concept of time, so seeing more of the picture means less time left. (We even have a song for it.)
Three key pieces made it work:
- I previewed the expectation before we started.
- I set a realistic expectation. The story said five minutes, even though when I tested it, they could do it in two.
- I used reinforcement, something they earn that makes the behavior more likely to happen again. In this case, an audiobook. An audiobook is the best reinforcer. I don't even have to be there.
The behavior changed almost immediately because the girls were so motivated.
You can also move things around. If bath time is where it falls apart, maybe bath happens right after school. That's a proactive strategy, meaning you set things up before the problem starts. Just know the battle may shift to a different signal, like "Time for jammies."
The "one more thing" stall
Here's the question I get all the time: "The routine is fine. But the second I say lights out, it's 'Wait, I didn't eat enough. I need water. I need a snack. I need a snuggle.'" Or you walk out, and every five minutes: "I need my water! Where's my stuffed animal?" That can drive me bonkers.
That's very likely attention. Could they just really want the water? Maybe. But if it's water, then a hug, then a stuffed animal, it's most likely attention.
So build it in, on purpose. After bath, teeth, jammies, hair, and books, instead of "Okay, lights out," say: "I'm going to set a timer for five minutes. We can snuggle, line up your stuffed animals, get water. This is your time."
We don't want to deny that your child needs attention. We want to say, "You want my attention? Great. It's available right now. I'm right here." And if a bedtime snack works in your family, this is the time for it, with some parameters.
Three ways to leave the room
Now it's time for you to leave. There are three approaches:
- Cold turkey. "I'm out of here. See you in the morning." Door closed.
- Move yourself out a little at a time. Lying with them, then sitting on the edge of the bed, then the foot of the bed, then by the door.
- Interval check-ins. This one is my favorite. You leave, then pop back in to check on them.
For check-ins, start with really small increments, maybe 30 seconds, with clear criteria: "If you're in your bedroom quietly, I'll come back." Make it super clear how your attention is available, and keep the timing realistic. The idea is that the intervals get longer and longer. Maybe the first night you pop in six or seven times, and a few days later it's five, and eventually you fade it out completely.
When you check in, or if they come out, use one sentence: "I love you very much, you're safe, I'll see you in the morning." Walk them back. Minimal words, stay calm, and be as consistent as you can.
They don't have to sleep. They do have to stay in their room.
We cannot control when a child actually falls asleep. What we can do is set the conditions around it.
In my house, the expectation for my girls was to be in their room quietly. They share a room, and I once recorded them on the monitor: they'd hang out for 10 or 15 minutes, talk, read books, turn off their light, and go to sleep. A couple of things are available to them, like a Toniebox or a book.
This needs to be monitored, and it depends on your kid. If yours are partying until 2 a.m., that might not work in your home. But the message is: you don't have to fall asleep, you do have to stay in your room quietly.
Struggling with all three? Start with bedtime.
If bedtime, night wakings, and early mornings are all your battle, pick one. Start with bedtime.
Here's why. If you're lying with your child until they fall asleep, and you're comfortable with that, great, rock on. But if it's too much for you, focus on the skill of falling asleep independently. A child who falls asleep with you there doesn't have the skills to get back to sleep alone when they wake up at night. A child who learns to fall asleep on their own can use that same skill at 2 a.m.
In my house, the reinforcer was chocolate milk. We had a little regression with Marley when she was four, so we went back to chocolate milk for a smooth nighttime routine: following her routine, staying in her room, and using her words for a calm bedtime. (We frame it positively. We don't say "for not crying.") She earned chocolate milk in the morning if her bedtime went the way we practiced.
If your child is waking up four times a night while you're working on bedtime, they still get the chocolate milk for bedtime. We're focusing on one thing. This is called shaping: building toward the big goal one small step at a time.
It will get worse before it gets better
When you change how you respond, expect an extinction burst. That's when the behavior gets worse before it gets better, because something that used to work isn't working anymore, so your child tries harder. (I explain more about how this works in Is It Defiance or Connection?)
I tell families they're going to be mad at me for about five days. You'll be sitting outside your child's room thinking, "Mandy was an idiot, I never should have listened to her, he's come out 15 times." That's fair. Wait.
Stick with it for at least 10 days. I can almost guarantee that days five and six will be significantly better. Not zero. Not perfect. But if you implement it with fidelity, meaning you do it the way we planned, every time (the one sentence, walking them back, the reinforcement, the preview), it will get better.
I worked with an American family living in Europe who were leaving on a six-week summer vacation in 10 days. I told the mom, "I don't know if you want to start this yet. It's going to take a couple of days." She said, "No, we're starting." She emailed me later: he came out 30 times the first night, 10 times the second night, twice the third night, and on the fourth night he said, "Good night, Mommy."
Then she said, "I don't think we had an extinction burst." That first night, all 30 times? That was the extinction burst.
For the kid who comes out again and again: set a "fewer than" goal
If your child comes out many, many times a night, try something called DRL, differential reinforcement of low rates of behavior. In plain English, you reward fewer times instead of zero. "If you come out five times or less tonight, you earn chocolate milk tomorrow." Give them a visual so they know where they stand. This may not be right for a two- or three-year-old, but it can work well for four- and five-year-olds.
Night wakings: the 2 a.m. visitor
Say bedtime is going well, but at midnight and 2 a.m., they're in your room every night. That's usually attention: "I want somebody to attend to me."
A few things you can do:
- Use DRL again. "If you wake up two times or less, you can earn."
- Teach what to do when they wake up. Add a page to the social story: "Sometimes I wake up in the middle of the night. That's okay, Mommy and Daddy do too. When I wake up, I can snuggle my stuffed animal, get a new blanket, or turn on some music. Mommy and Daddy are sleeping. Sleep is important for everyone. They love me very much, and they'll see me in the morning." Validate the feeling of waking up, and replace the behavior.
- Respond consistently. I have brought many sleeping children into my bed. No judgment here. But if the function is "I'm going to go snuggle Mom," and you say, "I'm so tired, get in here," that reinforces it. If it pays off sometimes, they'll keep trying, the same way I describe in Why Does My Kid Only Act Like This With Me?
Pick your timing. If you have a busy week at work, it might not be the week to start walking them back every single time.
The green light system (and why "it doesn't work")
For night wakings and early mornings, I'm a big fan of a green light: a light that changes color, so your child knows when it's okay to get up. (They're easy to find online, and some fancy ones change from your phone. I don't care how you do it.) Your child doesn't know the difference between 2 a.m. and 6 a.m., especially when it's still dark.
People tell me all the time, "We have a green light. It doesn't work." That's because we have to condition it, meaning we have to teach your child that green actually means something good. If your kid doesn't care about the light, it won't work.
So we do it errorlessly: we set it up so your child can't miss. Marley was getting up at 5:30 every morning. So I set her green light to turn green at 5:00. With a social story and reinforcement: if she stayed in bed until the light was green, she earned chocolate milk. She never woke up before 5:45, so there was no way she wasn't going to earn.
I want the light to be green when they wake up, so they come in contact with the reward. If you're not sure, set it to turn green at 3 a.m. I don't care. When the green light equals reinforcement, we can shape it.
I sat on the stairs that first morning, so excited. She came out, and it was high fives all around. Then, slowly, I moved the time later.
And I mean slowly. So many people tell me, "I moved it half an hour and it stopped working." We've got time, people. You've been waking up at 4 a.m. with them every day. It's okay if it's 5:15 for a couple of days. Move it five or ten minutes at a time until you get where you want to be.
Same idea for night wakings. If your child usually comes in around 2 a.m., set the light to turn green at 1:30: "If it's red, you stay in bed. If it's green, you can come to Mommy." Now they're earning. Then one night you see on the monitor that he woke up at 1:00, saw red, and stayed in bed because he wanted that chocolate milk. Then you move it back a little at a time.
How long do I have to keep rewarding this?
Reinforcement shouldn't be forever. But instead of just dropping it, here's what we did: we made the job bigger.
Once the early wake-ups were solved, I folded in getting dressed. Now, if you wake up and take your jammies off, you earn chocolate milk. A few weeks later: take your jammies off and put your pants on. Eventually, chocolate milk covered going to bed, staying in bed, and getting up and getting dressed. I'll still give chocolate milk for that.
Make it easy to win at first
When you start any plan:
- Start daily, and start low. Families tell me, "We have a star chart, and after five days they earn..." No. Start daily. You can fade it later.
- Isolate the reinforcer. Chocolate milk wasn't available to anyone at any other time except by earning it for staying in bed.
- Give it immediately.
This is not a gotcha. We want them to earn. We want them to be successful.
Be honest about your follow-through
I worked with one family for a couple of weeks on sleep. The mom told me it was a little better, but not where it needed to be. And I had to be direct: we need to implement this more strongly and be so consistent.
I know how hard that is. I have three of my own children, sometimes there are seven kids in this house, and I'm in the thick of it with a little one. So if it's not a good time, don't start. If you're going on vacation in a week, wait until you get back. If vacation is two weeks away and you start now, you might even be able to pack the green light.
This isn't only for little kids, either. I worked with a mom whose teenager kept coming into her bed. We used dollars on his kids' debit card as the reward, and moved the time back a little at a time.
Sleep is one of my favorite behaviors to work on. You get a chance to practice literally every day, and it can change really quickly with a strong plan.
FAQ
How do I stop my child from getting out of bed over and over? Build attention into the routine before lights out, then leave with a clear plan, like short interval check-ins. Each time they come out, walk them back with one calm sentence, and reinforce staying in their room. Expect it to get worse for a few days before it gets better, and stick with it for at least 10 days.
Why doesn't our green light clock work? Your child has to learn that the green light means something good. Set it to turn green before they usually wake up so they earn every time, pair it with a reward, then move it later in five- or ten-minute steps.
Should I work on bedtime, night wakings, or early mornings first? Start with bedtime. When a child learns to fall asleep on their own, they can use that same skill when they wake up in the middle of the night.
Does my child have to fall asleep right away? No. We can't control when a child falls asleep. A realistic expectation is that they stay in their room quietly, with a couple of calm options like a book.
A next step, if you want one
If you want a simple way to track the plan, grab a free Star Chart or AM/PM Star Chart from my free resources. Remember to start daily and start low. If you'd like help figuring out the function and building a sleep plan for your child, I do 1:1 coaching, and you can bring your bedtime questions to The Club.
Figure out the function, set it up so your child can win, and take it one small step at a time. You can do this.